PAULA MUST REMAIN. please please please tell me she is coming back! i will NOT watch AI without her! i only watch idol for her, im a super fan

i would miss him… but the most important person for me is PAULA. as long as shes on the show i will watch it. if she leaves- im out.

I would not watch! Simon is the only judge on there who actually can reconize good talent.

OMG are you serious!!!?? Simon IS american idol. He’s what makes it, if Simon weren’t on the show thoses golden rating would sink! You can’t have idol without Simon it’s impossible.

Simon is crucial part of American Idol.He is the only one that keeps it real. His unique ear for talant is priceless.Every contestant , every parent of contestant ,every veiwer wants to hear HIS opinion.Let’s get real Imerican Idol will go down without Simon. Love him !!!!!

Pleeze - Simon is American Idol!! People, pleeze. Kara should have been gone long b4 her 30 day probation period…. she sucks!

I watch the show because of Simon
he has the best eye and ear for good talent. I dont believe
Paula is also great

I LOVE SAMON!!! RANDY & PAULA CAN GO, BUT THEY WOULD HAVE TO TAKE THAT ANNOYING KARA WITH THEM. I WOULD CONSIDER THEM ALLOWING TO KEEP RANDY & PAULA IF THEY GOT RID OF KERA!! SHE REALLY WORK MY NERVES. GRUARRRRR!

Actually, I DON’T watch it because of Simon. I think he is the worst part of the show. People think that he’s real because he puts people down.He has no class

simon is american idol r u kidding they all can be repalced except for him get rid of that dumas ryan

Well I wouldn’t watch it without Simon and Paula both on the show.

Simon IS American Idol. Without him, there would be no show to watch, because it wouldn’t even last one episode. They would have to yank it in the middle and put up a test pattern.

I thought he was in the process of negotiating a new deal with Idol that would make him the highest paid star on TV.