For those of you who truly appreciate the life and work of Jeff Buckley, then you know this role requires a lot of depth. James Franco could bring this and James Pattison would be a seriously disappointing choice. Don’t get caught up in the Pattinson (Twilight) hype!!!

James Franco is the only choice here:

It’s ironic because the first time I saw a picture of Jeff Buckley, I thought he was Buckley’s doppelganger!
For the love of God, you can NOT cast the kid from Twilight. I’m sorry—he has way too much ‘type-cast’ baggage from his latest teen-vampire role.
Buckley is, single-handily, the most beautifulest person. His songs paint him as a Greek god.

Please, cast James Franco for the role.

I always going to vote for my rob ALWAYS

pattinson play very very cool!!!
he is sexy in the scene!!!

James actually looks like Jeff a lot more than Rob. I think either of them could pull off the singing or they wouldn’t be considered for the role in the first place, so since James resembles Jeff more, I’d say him. Just because we’ve seen Rob on youtube doesn’t mean that James has zero musical talent.

I think either one could do a really good job. Yea, the look of the role is important but it should also be based on who has the better audition. The one who could convince the casting director that they can add to the role more, who can make their job easier by casting them because they can offer more to the role. James or Rob could do a great job.

Sure, James Franco has a longer, more illustrious, filmography, and reputedly looks more like Jeff Buckley, but Robert Pattinson is a very talented musician with an incredible gift of mimicry, as well as being a real chameleon (have you seen how different he looks in pictures??). Not to mention he is probably the most bankable actor in the world right now.

So if it’s a matter of voting, the vote goes to Robert Pattinson. (Hope it matters.)

hmmm..have u guys heard of rob’s singing?? certainly not..noo..rob is a great actor..but we need to see more of his acting skills b4 he took such a big role like this..james fraco will be great 4 that part..

Both actors are talented, but in terms of casting a bankable actor in the role, Robert Pattinson is a sure winner. He has such a legion of fans world wide that you could cast him in a cornflakes commercial and people would pay to go and see it.

Franco Looks more like Jeff Buckley than RPattz does. Not sure of his vocals though. Personally, Rob has talent that reaks and should be used in more constructive way than impersonating a gloomy singer.

Rob is the one with the beautiful Sexy voice and could really play Buckley. He is a fantastic musician and I love his voice. It really turns me on!

This is a tough one, but I think Rob wins by a nose. His musical talent should make the difference.

Pattinson himself said that Franco would probably get the part, because he looks so much like Buckley. Doesn’t mean he shouldn’t get a chance to audition and show what he can do. Biopics are always a bit soulless when they make the actors mime. So I do hope they use the actor’s voice, in which case, Pattinson does have an edge.

I’m for Franco!!!!!
He’s a very talented actor, sings beautifully also (remember SNL). Besides, James Franco looks a lot more like Jeff Buckley than Pattinson. I hope he gets it. And Rob has no talent.
Musical talent for this movie is not so important, because there will be a phonogram of Jeff Buckley.

Franco:
- good actor (2 points)
- looks like Buckley (2 point)

Pattinson:
- unknown quantity acting wise, but has potential (1 point)
- kind of looks like Buckley, but not so much (1 point)
- great voice (3 points)

=> Franco, 4
Pattinson, 5

I think Franco is a better actor than Pattinson (not to mention he could be made to look exactly like Jeff) so I voted for him. The only edge Pattinson has on Franco is that he has a good voice.

I actually like Franco, but I don’t think he should get the part just because he happens to look like Jeff Buckley. Pattinson has real musical talent, and a unique soulful voice. That’s much more relevant to who Buckley really was. I’m for Pattinson.

O tuff one. Rob has an amazing edge to his voice when he sings. a edgeness, which reminds me of Jeff Buckley. But i have to say, James really does look like him. I don’t know :( i think i’d like to see Rob do it more though

Pattinson has immense musical skills. A fantastic voice and a huge following for his music. Just go check out You tube. This role needs someone with those skills. You cant fake it. He has a soulful voice as did Buckley. Its a perfect match. If Pattinson has a chance to audition I think he’d get it but I think its sadly already a done deal.