VOTE: Did 'The Bachelor' Pick the Right Woman?
In a shocking "Bachelor" twist, Jason Mesnick proposed to Melissa Rycroft, and the 25-year-old sales rep happily accepted -- only to have him dump her for the other finalist, 24-year-old Molly Malaney!

Melissa stormed off the set, heartbroken, while Molly agreed to give her relationship with Jason another shot.
Tell "Extra" -- did Jason ultimately pick the right girl?
"Extra" friends couldn't believe Jason pulled a switch-a-roo on Melissa and Molly -- can you? Discuss this in our community now!


























Melissa asking Jason “I asked Jason, ‘Am I going to be blind-sided by anything? Is there anything you want to tell me?’ And he said, ‘No, gosh no.’ And the second I went out on that stage, he goes, ‘P.S. it is Molly.’ And I went, ‘Bastard!’”
Producer Mike Fleiss says, Q: Jason said repeatedly that he was contractually obligated to break up with Melissa on the air. What was his contract?
A: I think he felt an obligation to the show, but there’s no contractual obligation there. None.
Q: So Jason did not have to break up with Melissa on the show?
A: He definitely had time to tell her before … You can check the contracts. How would you put that into a contract anyway? It’s impossible.
Q: Did Jason ever tell you he didn’t want to dump Melissa on camera?
A: I never heard that.
March 27, 2009