Community Buzz: Which 'Idol' Hopeful Should Get the Boot?

"Extra" Friends are buzzing about the next group of "American Idol" contestants and the early favorites. Friend Hallie says, "After 8 seasons, 'American Idol' was getting a little boring. I'm glad Nick [Mitchell] is on because he is unique."

0226idolchat.jpg

Tell us which "Idol" wannabe you think should stay or go --
join the conversation!

comments

just hoping math giraud ricky braddy & megan win in wild card


from phillippines manila
sandy

sandy
March 6, 2009

Last night was horrible. The songs chosen and performed were poor and no one other than Adam stepped up to the plate.

dee
February 26, 2009

Honestly, this season of idol is looking very grim so far, in fact its verging on terrible. If you look at the previous idol winners, and some non winners as well, can u truthfully say that anyone from this season comes close? NO! Danny is by far the best, i can actually see him putting out an album and selling records, because he is a good singer, not for pity. People r crazy if they think hes getting through as the pity vote, open your eyes people! Oh an Nick/Norman whatever, needs to go asap. He needed to go the first audition. People r losing sight of what this show is all about, yes we want entertainment but we r looking and voting for someone to be the next American Idol. Someone who can put out an album, have songs on the radio, maybe someday be at the grammy’s. All im saying is season 8 needs to definitly step it up!!!

stefanie
February 26, 2009

Stay: Allison, Adam and Meghan. Everyone else was terrible. Danny Gokey needs to get better to stay in the game, the “poor me” act wont last long. and really, norman? you people do realize that this is a serious singing competition..what kind of album would he made? answer:none. he would be dropped from any label because he is ridiculous.

Anonymous
February 26, 2009

Danny is my favorite. I think he has an awesome voice…….he doesn’t need any pity votes! Nick (Norman) was so much fun to watch. My kids loved him…
they made me watch his performance three times! I felt great to laugh after a long work day. I hope to see him again…..

Lynn
February 26, 2009

seriously, danny gokey wasnt even the best in the first 12. he got the pity vote and he was placed by the producers at the end so people will remember him better. ricky braddy was sooooo much better. gokey’s results show performance was rough. he was out of tune a lot.

masha
February 26, 2009

i think that adam lambert should win!!!! hes like totally the best and hes the next zac efron/robert patterson and nick should also win… gosh hes funny….. then mishovanna should also win… she sings pretty…. and she IS pretty… all my friends agree!….. atleast not the ones from school cause they dont actually watch american idol but the other ones do!we all agree so please… atleast adam lambert and mishovanna they ARE the best!!!

kimberly
February 26, 2009
post comment


(not displayed)


Back to Top »