Thankgod Taylors coming back, replacing him would be like replacing Emma Watson or Rupert Grint from their roles in Harry Potter.

As for the little Vanessa issue, i don’t think she is able to play strong Leah, who’d have thought she’d go for a role where she turns out to be a big hairy wolf?

And i don’t think she really fits the description, Leah is supposed to be athletic and tall, and always have an unhappy look on her face.

Vanessa couldn’t keep an unhappy face on for more than a minute, after all she is a disney dancer. Personally i think i’d be waiting for her to break into song.

now way! vannessa shouldnt be leah! she’s like 5ft and leah is like 6ft!!!

I swear 2 god they better NOT hire vanessa!!!!
I mean wth?!!! Disney idiots DonT mix in twilight!!!
No mo no!!!

YUCK, vanessa…I didn’t even like HSM, I don’t think she should be in a movie like Twilight, let her stick to corny kiddy movies.

NOOO PLEEAAASEE NOOOO
NOT VANESSA SHE’S FROM DISNEY !!!
SHE’S JUST EWWW
THEY’LL RUIN IT IF SHE’S LEAH

YAY TALOR!!!! But FYI for the rest of you Vanessa would fit the desciption of Leah and she did have other movie roles besides Disney movies.

I am so happy Taylor’s coming back, It would really lame if their was a different actor for each movie. As for Vanessa Hudgens she’s just not Twilight material, she’s a disney star.I will be very upset if they do cast her.. They Can’t because common Leah is like this super though warewolf I really don’t think she could pull it off, she should just stick with Disney Channel Movies.Well thats what I think many feel the same way I’m Glad Im not alone.

OMG NO NO NO NO NOT Vanessa hudgens I mean shez a Disney Star N does NOT BELONG IN MOVIES LIKE TWILIGHT SERIES!!! Im not a fan nor hater of you BUT NO U WILL TOTALLY RUIN THE MOVIE!!! AND BESIDES UR A DISney Star So NO!!

As for Taylor Im not a jacob team person but I am STILL SOOOO Happy dey kept him because I mean hez a great jacob n makes the movie GREAT!!!

To be completely honest I am not a fan of Vanessa Hudgens. I think she is a poor role model for younger children (ie. naked pictures, smoking, etc). I dont care if she is a disney star. I am simply not a fan of her. If she gets a part in New Moon she will ruin it for all the fans. I am glad to read I am not the only one who feels this way.

In regards to Taylor, I am extremely excited to see him in New Moon. I think he will do a great job!

ps:: Ashley Greene is such a sweetheart. She has an amazing future ahead of her. And I can’t wait to see where life takes her.

Is it November yet?

NO!NO!NO!NO!
NO!
Vanessa CAN NOT I repeat CAN NOT be in Twilight. Shes a disney star for crying out loud. Disney stars to not belong in movies like Twilight.
JUST NO!
UHH!
I don’t hate her, I just aren’t fond of her.
IT WOULD RUIN THE MOVIE.

If Vanessa gets hired… i’ll cry! I can’t stand her. I pray that it’s just a rumor.

Oh nooo way!!!!!!Vanessa CAN NOT BE part of the movies.GOD…It nearly gave me a heartattack…NO NO AND NO!Sorry Vanessa…New Moon deserves better than you!
BTW I’m so happy for Taylor.He’s such a cute person…and he is perfect for Jacob.

I don’t hate her, I just don’t care about her, but NO, NO WAY… she doesn’t fit ANYWHERE in Twilight!!!!!

no not vannessa!! ugh i hate her!!!

It’s absolutely awesome that Taylor is returning. He’s probably the only non-Native that I can accept in a Native American role. As for Vanessa? No. Leah is a tough gal. Disney actresses cannot portray Leah adequately because Disney stars tend to have to have a”cutesy” factor to them to even have their jobs. If they put anyone “cute” in Leah’s role, it’ll ruin it.

ewwww!! vanessa hudgens is the WORST actress ever!! please dont let her in the BEST story ever!

Okay, for vanessa, is she that stupid to even audition for a part her acting skills are aparently not strong enough for display? Especially in New Moon, with Leah’s difficult personality in the book. It will take a serious actor to capture it, which is definately not Hudgens.

Number two, I can just imagine all the grade school students of all ages(including 6,7, or 8 year olds) flocking to a movie that she is in just because she is in HSM. Now, I don’t have a problem with sharing the book and movie with others, but I definately do not think it is appropiate for those age groups.(though the movie makers will definately earn more money and not care). Besides, they will have the additude of OH MY GOSH I LOVEEE TWILIGHT, when apparently they won’t understand the movie, let alone the series. I can barely stand the middle schoolers that claim to love twilight more than life itself because of the movie.

ie. two reasons explained why vanessa would be a terrible choice.

p.s. good luck for taylor, though I was rooting for one of the older guys..

LOL Ashley is soo cute xD

anyways ==’.

hmmp no disney stars for new moon or any of the twilight squeals.

look i thunk Vanessa would be an okayish person in new moon but rember that she is NOT with disney any more they arent making high school musical any more number 1 and number two diney channel like fired her because of those naked pictures she had so she wont be bringing disney into twilight i guess but i imagined leah like ALOT and i mean ALOT prettier then Venessa and more (please dont anyone take this personally please!) more like Native american looking not like hispanic looking ang no offince

Vanessa Hudgens as Leah… I highly doubt that would happen.
Leah’s too hardcore for a disney star :P
Especially Vanessa.

I’m happy for Taylor, though! I’m really curious to see how he does the unhappy-Jacob, since he seems so bouncy.