VOTE: Would 'Idol' Be Better without Paula?

Rumors have been swirling that "American Idol's" Paula Abdul is planning on leaving the hit FOX show after season 8 -- leaving fans wondering how much she brings to the judging table!

1215idol.jpg

Tell "Extra" -- Would "American Idol" be better with or without Paula?

comments

Paula is the reason why I watch the sow, she cannot leave!

Flower
December 17, 2008

Paula should not leave the show. It won’t be on for that much longer and it won’t make sense if she leaves now. She helps make the show what it is and and they also don’t need a fourth judge. No one wants to see another judge. Hopefully no one will like her and she will only be on for one season. The judges and Ryan make the show what it is and they have really good chemistry, a fourth judge will ruin it. What is wrong with just three judges. I also don’t like the changes that they are doing with the show. The ratings will probably be worse this coming season.

Maddie
December 16, 2008

Bye Bye to Paula! Won’t miss her. Most of the time she doesn’t make sense because she seems waisted. American Idol is a great show and will continue to be great without Paula.

Vickie
December 15, 2008

Waz up, this LiL’ Gang$ta,
from U.T.B.,
I Think that Idol needs Paula!!!,
It wouldn’t be tha same wit out her!!!, God willin’ she isn’t going to leave the show, EVER!!!,
Come Check me out @
www/MySpace.com/LiLG75

LiL' Gang$ta
December 15, 2008

Paula is as important to the show as Simon is. We love her.

bevierose
December 15, 2008

Like Paula and think she should stay. She is a good balance for the other two!

Jane
December 15, 2008

OMG! If Paula leaves I think I would cry! Paula is the major reasin I watch the show! (Excapt for the talent and hilarious auditions of course!) I think Paula should ABSOLUTELY stay…..she would be very tough shoes to fill….

Anonymous
December 15, 2008

Paula Abdul absolutely has got to go…when she speaks I mute the TV and thank God I have a DVR so II can fast forward past her segments. The decision for her to go is long over due. BILL

Bill In Texas
December 15, 2008

Puala should stay.I mean,without Paula then who would fight with Simon?Puala let’s the contastants down easy.That’s what’s so unique about the judges,they all have their own personality.Even making 1 of the judges leave,that will ruin everything.

coolkid
December 15, 2008

Beautiful Paula, You are a BEAUTY and a sweetheart and Simon should be ashamed of how he treats you. He has to answer one day for his actions. Then we will see how bad he really is!! Your seat will be hard to fill. GOOD LUCK IN ALL YOU DO—YOU ARE A DOLL AND WE LOVE YOU!

Sandee Rice
December 15, 2008

Paula leaving would be sad, Simon is the one who should go - his horrible negative nasty comments are a disgrace- he teaches the ultimate course in how NOT to be NICE to others. Most of the crazies you see on the tryouts are sad pathetic souls. Just humor them without the nasty remarks and move on - what purpose is there for the negativity. Is he trying to make people feel bad about themselves ? I think most of them already do.

Happy in PA
December 15, 2008

The show needs Paula! She is such a beautiful and talented lady in her own right. She knows the talent and has a unique way of reining in Simon when he is totally off-base. Her and Randy are a GREAT team! The show is nothing without her! Now, that 4th judge they are talking about - yuck! Give her the axe before it even starts. Whose lame idea was/is that?

Laura
December 15, 2008

I’m sorry but Paula is so annoying on the show. She never makes any sense as she stumbles over her words and looks lost most of the time. It’s long over due, she needs to go!!!

Anonymous
December 15, 2008

Are you people kidding?She has made the show a joke for years. She is drugged up and useless. She never gives any constructive comments and pretty much just babbles. The show would have more credibility without here

Topher
December 15, 2008

I think Paula needs a break from all the things that have been going on with the stalker. She needs a rest which would do her very good for a change.

dolores terhune
December 15, 2008

Sorry Paula, this viewer says adios is overdue. It’s been a long time waiting for you to make a point, make a choice, and leave the emotions for another show at another time.

Kelly
December 15, 2008

I like Paula, I think she needs to get away from the two guys. I wish Randy would leave the show.

Thelma Chumbley
December 15, 2008

If paula leaves it wouldnt be american idol!! It would be like a show with sequels and we know that they are never as good as the original! I think if paula leaves it would lose alot of viewers!

Tina
December 15, 2008

i don’t watch the show much, but I love Paula Abdul very much. I hate to see her leave the show.

George Jobson
December 15, 2008

Sorry..It would be REALLY SAD!

Scott
December 15, 2008
post comment


(not displayed)


Back to Top »