sign up for the Extra newsletter

April 23, 2008

'Phantom' Star Reviews 'Idol' Performance

Current star of "Phantom of the Opera" on Broadway, Howard McGillin, gives "Extra" his review of David Cook's performance on last night's "American Idol."


NEXT: Beyoncé and Jay-Z: At Last, It's Official

 

David Cook is a SUPERSTAR!!! He can sing anything put in front of him. At this point, there is not competition. If America has an ounce of taste, David Cook should win EASY!!!


- David Cook Fanny
Posted 04/24/08 12:38 AM
 

Extra, Thank you so much for posting this. So many people are talking about this performance without really knowing what they’re talking about. The difference in context is key and in the context of television rather than Broadway, David did indeed nail it.

I’ve just listened to the Studio Version which I got from ITunes, which is quite different from the performance version. I love both of them and am so proud of David. He got the chance to let his inner theatre nerd out and to show his admiration for Sir Andrew.


- Kate
Posted 04/23/08 11:58 PM
 

Yes, David Cook did do it beautifully. I am still trying to pick up my jaw off the floor. Simon preferred David to do a little rock edge but that would have touched a song that should never, ever be messed up. You don’t mess with Music of the Night. It’s iconic and David really did nail it and it is a very difficult song to sing that few people can carry off. this proves who is the most talented, well rounded with unbelievable range.


- Veronica
Posted 04/23/08 05:36 PM
post comment

Name

Email
(not displayed)
remember me?     

Back to Top »