Tonia has tried every way imaginable to score a good man: blind dates, bars, the Internet.

With nowhere else to turn, Tonia came to “Extra’s” search for America’s Most Eligible.

Here’s the scoop on Tonia: she’s single, 36 and from Colorado. She is also pretty, successful and sings in a class rock band! All that’s missing is a great man.

After picking Michael Teh from our group of Eligible Bachelors, Tonia and Michael both gave “Extra” an update halfway through their date. Will they exchange numbers or just continue living the single life?

Watch the video below to find out!

Click on an image to RATE THESE BACHELORS now!