sign up for the Extra newsletter

March 9, 2007

Antonella's Out, as 'Idol's' Top 12 Are Revealed!


The final note sounded off Thursday night for Antonella Barba, as America bids adieu to the "Idol" who made more headlines for her racy photos than for singing.

"I think it's a lot of pressure for a young girl to have to deal with as well as to try to do well on a show like this," Simon Cowell admitted.

And at Thursday night's "American Idol" Top 12 party, the "Idol's" had lots to say to our Terri Seymour about the New Jersey native's too hot for TV photos.

"I feel so bad for Antonella," dished Chris Richardson. "She's such a great person."

But Antonella wasn't the only one to get the boot, as America bid farewell to Jared Cotter and Sundance Head, whose night took a tragic turn when he learned that the cousin who had helped pay for expenses during his "Idol" auditions died in a devastating house fire.

"He didn't find out until after," admitted Chris Sligh. "I'm not a crier, and I cried when Sundance left."

The night had even more shocks, as the talented Sabrina Sloan also got cut.

"How many times have I said to these contestants choose the right songs. And they never listen. It's the songs in the case of Sundance and Sabrina why they're out of the competition," Judge Dread revealed.

But the biggest surprise of the night was the announcement of "Idol Gives Back," a two-night special in April that could have a staggering global effect as it raises money for people in poverty, both in Africa and America.

"It's something we've kept quiet for two years. It's been a long time in the making," Simon confessed.

The special, which will feature performances from music heavyweights Gwen Stefani, Pink and Josh Groban, has special meaning for Simon, who went to poverty-stricken Africa with Ryan Seacrest in January.

"They need some help," Simon said.

And "Extra" traveled with Simon and Ryan on the trip, and will have exclusive additional footage in the weeks to come.

"When this show has done so well for all of us, it's cool to give something back," Simon said of "Idol's" astronomical success.

And in the spirit of giving back, Mr. Mean was ready to give a few extra jabs to the remaining "Idols," especially Sanjaya, who is having trouble settling on a singing style and a hair style.

"Let me tell you this. He's not going to win," Simon said of the fickle wannabe. "I won't be back if he does."


NEXT: Salma Hayek: Engaged and Expecting!

 

Idols should be judged like Rockstar INXS and Rockstar Supanova. On the night, the three with the lowest votes get to sing again,and the judges decide who goes home. You cannot leave it to the public. The public vote for who they LIKE and not who can SING. It should be up to the judges.


- Idols Fan
Posted 04/12/07 06:51 AM
 

Go Sanjaya! votefortheworst! lolz


- me
Posted 03/15/07 06:36 AM
 

hey Meko, how is posing for a photographer in tasteful lingerie nasty porn???


- ladytex
Posted 03/14/07 02:14 PM
 

JMOOD, you people always play the race card!


- Katie
Posted 03/14/07 01:38 PM
 

It sad when you have to let somebody go that has come this far, but let’s face it.. “American Idol” is all about finding the best singer and not the best looking!!!


- pj
Posted 03/14/07 12:30 PM
 

Oh and another thing. Half of those pictures aren’t even her. Losers!!!..LOL


- Meko
Posted 03/12/07 01:02 PM
 

WOW!!!! You guys are haters. She may not have had the best voice but she has potential. I hope she grows into a mature and sucessful musician. And who doesn’t have explicit photos of themsleves??And if you don’t, who has the right to comment.. Just the insecure people. As far as Ms. Frenchie goes, I love the girl, but its a difference between racey and just flat out nasty porn. homegirl should be ashamed!!.. Thats why she was booted… for being tasteless, but the girl can sang!!!


- meko
Posted 03/12/07 12:59 PM
 

Hey!
This comment is for the blogger whose name is posted as “style”!!!!
SHUT UP AND JUST LEAVE A COMMENT ABOUT THE TOPIC GIVEN BY EXTRA!!!
DO NOT TAKE IT UP ON YOURSELF TO ANSWER A BLOGGER!
ESPECIALLY NOT ME!!!

YOU”LL BE JOINING ANTONELLA IN HELL TOO! SAY HELLO TO HER FOR ME WHEN BOTH OF YOU GET THERE!!!!!!!


- blah!
Posted 03/12/07 07:06 AM
 

I am glad she was kicked off. She was not a good singer. She was put thru after forgetting her words in Hollywood and the girl sitting beside as the last two, to find out if they were going thru, was better. The other people that forgot their words were sent packing. I think she got thru from her looks and that she could get ratings.


- Maryann
Posted 03/11/07 12:08 PM
 

First of all, she was a terrible singer and second of all, why is it that Frenchie got kicked off while the white girl gets to stay? Interesting.


- jmood
Posted 03/11/07 11:54 AM
 

Antonella should not be out of A. Idol, I know she could be better.

Her problem wasn’t her voice at all, but the stupid guy who did something totally wrong.

Antonella keep going, you will make it!!!!!!!!!


- Edith Tomicic
Posted 03/11/07 11:01 AM
 

There are a couple of things going on here.

One being that Antonella doesn’t have the voice quality to win American Idol.She knows it and perhaps used this venue to ‘get noticed’.Would her pictures on the internet have gotten so much notice otherwise?

Another thing is Americal Idol allowing her to be on the show in the first place.Wasn’t research done beforehand on all the contestants? Are we to believe that the photos suddenly appeared during the competition and not earlier? This whole thing has gotten AI as much publicity as well as it has gotten Antonella publicity.

Also,the camera shots of her parents weren’t those of embarrassement. They just don’t look uncomfortable enough to have suddenly learned of their minor daughter’s raunchy photos splattered on the internet.

AND…these are not professional photos.I can’t believe that she is the only young girl that has photos like that.Surely there are MANY college aged girls that have taken similar photos - at parties or where ever - they just haven’t submitted them, or if they have submitted them, they aren’t on a nationally viewed weekly television show.

So…I think this whole thing is just an attention getter for everyone involved.The publicitiy people have done their jobs well.I really don’t think that if AI is the family friendly program it professes to be,they would not have allowed this girl to get to Hollywood if they were not planning all of this from the get go.Both sides are winning here, there is no ‘loser’, and both will continue to benefit from the attention for quite a while.

Mickeyfan


- mickeyfan
Posted 03/11/07 07:02 AM
 

My comment about American Idol is to pick the right song and people should listen to them even if they don’t like it cause they might get better. Antonella should have not got kicked off it should have been Chris cause he can’t sing at all. And Rosie O’Donald needs to keep her mouth shut to cause my mom said she is getting sick in tired of her, I am to. Thank you!


- Vena
Posted 03/10/07 11:31 PM
 

Re: AMERICAN IDOL GIVES BACK!
Wonderful Idea for their show , but somehow I can’t quite picture Simon caring one diddly squat beyond himself. Not after asking one of the contestants what they would do with their winnings and upon their replying that they would donate to charity , Simon rolled his eyes in exasperation. !!
Did Simon suddenly visit the “WIZARD OF OZ” to get a heart???


- Kayla
Posted 03/10/07 04:50 PM
 

People who sit in judgement of others are not good role models either. In fact, doesn’t the church still teach people about hypocrisy?


- Style
Posted 03/10/07 04:06 PM
 

Antonella will probably end up rich doing something or the other! The only question I have for you is….. will the money she gets from possibly being in playboy magazines or in porn or whatever she might do in the future be a gift to her from God or from Satan?

I think Satan.
All the money in the world will not save her from the fiery gates of hell when it’s all over for her!!
She is definitely not a saint and there is no excuse for her pornographic pics on the internet….(DO NOT POST A COMMENT UNLESS YOU RESEARCH THESE PICS FIRST———OR WHAT YOU SAY DOES NOT COUNT>>>>>>>>> SEE FOR YOURSELF!!!!! FORGET THE LAME EXCUSES FOR HER ACTIONS!)
All the BEAVER DEFENDERS NEED TO SHUT UP AND GO SEE FOR THEMSELVES!!!!
SHE ONLY USED A.I AS A PLATFORM TO BECOME FAMOUS! SOON SHE”LL BE SHAVING HER HEAD LIKE THE PSYCHOTIC DEPRESSSED BRITNEY SPEARS AND SOON SHE’LL BE NOT AS ATTRACTIVE AFTER ALL THE PLASTIC SURGERY SHE HAS DONE OR WILL DO!!!!!!!
ONLY TIME WILL TELL!
I HOPE SHE REALLY BECOMES A MORE STABLE MINDED INDIVIDUAL WHEN IT COMES TO EXPOSING HER INTIMATE DETAILS OF HER LIFE ONLINE…
THERE’S HOPE FOR EVERYONE! EVEN HER!
SHE STILL HAS A CHANCE TO CHANGE AND HAVE A BETTER FUTURE…..


- blah!
Posted 03/10/07 01:59 PM
 

There is no need to talk in this way about Antonella, or call her promiscuous. Which she may not be, as I am sure she can afford to be very choosy and there are not that many great men around. She is not and could not, cause other American girls to want to pose like her, if they did not want to. Also, it is well known girls are sexually active from a far younger age, and they readily admit to it, thinking it very clever. Just look at the Myspace site to see all the very young girls who are asking for their webcam to be looked at and offers made to them.~~~~~~ Statistically, young people are not innocent, and insulting Antonella which has been done to a great extent is very cruel. Most, if not all the celebrities started that way, and now Antonella is going to be a very rich girl. She will not even have to go too far, but is famous enough to name her price. She will probably end up on Playboy. And how many men would turn down a chance to date a model from that magazine? It will mean a notch on their belt to brag about. I just hope Antonella will soon find a genuine young man, fall in love and stay safe.


- Donni-Jay
Posted 03/10/07 08:43 AM
 

My previous comments about American Idol explained the importance of picking the right song to suit the vocal range as well as the tone of voice, along with the right key. This seems obvious to most singers, and so it just shows the inexperience of those in this competition. That statement does not include Melinda Doolittle, who is incredible, with the most spectacular huge voice and by far the person who should win. American Idol, should look for at least half the standard of the voice of Christine Aguilara, for entrance into the future competitions. Back to the here and now; Sligh has the best male voice, but that was not too hard to hear, as the other male voices are so high and girly. Now why on earth do they sing like that? It is horrible. Very sad for Sundance’s loss, as his very supportive cousin died in a house fire.


- Donni-Jay
Posted 03/09/07 04:57 PM
post comment

Name

Email
(not displayed)
remember me?     

Back to Top »