Ian, You are the the best. Don’t listen to those haters. I love you.. You really made my daythe night I saw you on American Idol. Good luck to you…. Kisses

Ian YOU !@#$ing IDIOT!!!! YOU DON’T SING! YOU TALK! AND THAT’S ALL YOU DO!!!! YOU HAVE ABSOLUTELY HAVE NO TALENT WHATSOEVER!!!!! ONE MORE THING, NO ONE WEARS CHINCHILLA! A MAN DOES NOT WEAR FUR! ARE YOU A MAN? NO YOU’RE NOT, IF i SEE YOU ON THE STREET,I’D PUNCH YOUR LIGHTS OUT! YOU !@#$ING IDIOT!

Ian is a very nasty person….And he CANT sing….Since he wants to be judgemental, I shall also, Ian…my dogs howling sounds better than your sad attempt at singing. Why would you even think of going on tv and embarrassing yourself with THAT horrid voice??

i dont like you you punk

I’m so glad that u told Simon off. I think u represented New York City very well. Keep doing your thing and one day all ur dreams will come true!

Ian - I love ya! I think you make funny TV! Idol knew exactly what they wanted and that was ratings! Look William Hung couldn’t sing but he got fame and a record deal out of it! Go on Ian! I love the Long Island accent! If you need a friend to go shopping with - call me! lol

Ian - you gave me a reason to stop watching Extra. You have no talent and can’t handle criticism. Grow up for heavens sake. And, get your facts straight about Simon before you make such a fool of yourself.

This guy obviously doesn’t like people very much; the way he was treated on Idol - which was justified - is similar to the nasty comments and faces he made after speaking to “fans” on the street. Just because you’re an obnoxious narcissist doesn’t mean you should be on t.v.

he is the reason there are bad people on american idol. They know that they will get recognized and maybe make some money. Lets see, if i was gay and sucked, that means I can go on television and maybe make some money without doing anything. tell the bum to get a life and stop trying to be somebody when he is a nobody.

I think that Ian is the fruitiest person i have seen on tv in a long time. When I look at infantile young crossdressers like him on TV, I always think “wow, now that i know that guy isnt a MAN,and wont be dating girls, there is now more women out there for me”

In regards to all these nasty comments about some poor young man that THE MEDIA DECIDED TO MAKE A JOKE OF, have a heart folks, this guy needs theraphy and to be on medication, or in a halfway home somewhere. I can only imagine what his parents were like and the abuse he probably suffered at the hands of them. I think it’s a good time for Mr. Trump to step in and donate $10 grand to enable Ian to get into a good mental institution or, for Rosie step in to put him on the right road and under her arm. If only he had a friend to tell him the truth, one with a Dr. prefix in front of their name. Pathetic and Sad, SHAME ON YOU MEDIA!

Ian just quit being a 2 year old and stop acting like a brat and GET OVER IT! You will never be an american idol and will never be the winner of “So You Think You Can Dance”! Actually think about trying something that you’re good at!

Ian, being loud and obnoxious like Simon proves only one thing, do not try to change the nature of the competition. It is for singers, not musicians, actors and others who just want the spotlight. You had it. BTW, I have heard your music. It is not bad but you are not a singer.

Ian, You recieved your 5 mintues of fame. And it says be fa real .People like you make the real auditioners look bad. Get a life!!!!

People of AI gave him an audition because they knew he would be controversial and entertaining!! Nigel is the producer of both shows….Gimme a break people….like they didn’t know this would happen? It’s all about ratings? So what if Ian used AI to get exposure…AI used him to get the ratings and the Buzz. It WORKED!!

Ian told Nigel to go back to England on “So You Think You Can Dance”. He didn’t get post show attention for acting like a fool on that show, and you shouldn’t be giving him attention now. He’s getting exactly what he wanted, television exposure!

OMG!!!! WHAT A FREAK, I CANT BELIEVE U GUYS EVEN GAV HIM THA TIME OF DAY!!!! NOT 2 MENTION AIRTIME ON MORE THAN 1 OCCASION!!! HE SHOULD B GIVIN A RAFT N SENT OUT 2 THA MIDDLE OF THA OCEAN WHERE HIS VOICE N ATTITUDE WILL B APPRIECATED BY THA ONLY 1 WHO EVENS CARES, HIMSELF….UHHH I REALLY HOPE I NEVER SEE HIS FACE OR HEAR HIS VOICE AGAIN…I WOULD LUV 2 CONTINUE WATCHIN UR SHOW BUT IF HE CONTINUES 2 B AIRED ON EXTRA IM NOT SURE I CAN FATHOM IT……

This guy is an idiot…get him OFF the screen!!!!!

Ian is actually funny, well he had me laughing. I believe he would certainly do well in showbiz people want to see him, and he is entertaining. He could be the next Jack in “Will and Grace.” It’s not every day you get to tell off a phenomenal critic, Simon Cowell. Besides what would you do if you had 30 seconds of stardom?

I LOVE Ian Benardo’s lips.

Sethru’n in Boston