oh ya one thing i forgot u where write about one thing it isnt goiing to be 15 minutes but instead of what u siad about 15 years dont think so. More like 15 seocnds. I cant wait tell someone beets u up

Please do not show this idiot anymore. He is obnoxious and worse than Hung. This is the down side to the idol auditions. Having to see this type of person get any kind of attention is an insult to the viewers who watch your show. It is not newsworthy or entertaining. I turn the channel everytime they show this type of clip.

If I see this bum one more time on Extra i’ll stop watching the show because it will be showing me that Extra is running out of something to share with the public.

How can someone who looks tragically homeless (and has nothing better to do than fail t.v. auditions) talk nonsense about other people’s appearance and the fact that they have a job to go to every morning?

What’s wrong with this country?

Ian Benardo. Good freaking grief!

Hey Ian,
ur so funny i love you! don’t listen to those other people, they don’t know what the hell they’re talking about. Your need to get your own show. kk byes

I believe I’ve figured out how a loser like this gets fifteen minutes of fame. It’s because after you’ve seen someone this dumb, rude and full of himself, it’s very easy to feel good about yourself. His talent range is more narrow than the space between his eyes, his ego is bigger than his two front teeth, and his speech pattern is like the illegitimate son of Valley Girl and George W. Bush. Look at Ian, then look in the mirror and tell me how you possibly could NOT feel good about yourself.

hey my name is angie. And ian.. ur pathedic.. ur here giving people advice and stuff. and ur here thinking ur famous. and ur not.. ! get over your self pleasee. And my question to you is.. why do you think ur so awsome .. cuz ur not ! simon is a hottie and your a nottie !

take off your headband while you stop being a loser, youre so ugly inside and out, grow up and stop wasting our time.

I love the post with the reference to Kevin Federline, ha, good one. That’s about it too. Why don’t we ask Ian and his look alike KFed what they are doing about the War in Iraq, The Hunger in Africa, and the Katrina victims as well as others. By the way Ian, where does your income come from, are you just on holidays right now from your job or, are my dear Amercian neighbours supporting you with their tax dollars. There you go bigshot, answer those questions. Oh, and while you’re at it, “Fer crying out loud man, get a life.”

Pathetically Sad. Shame on You Media.

Ian,
Since I first saw you on American Idol I would like to offer you this advice: Find an agent in Hollywood as soon as you can, you are the only original, fresh face that has come onto the entertainment scene. Get your face in front of every camera you can.

OK EXTRA, this guy has had his 15 minutes of fame and he should go home quietly. It’s images like his antics and attitude that add to the antics and attitude of today’s youth. WE DO NOT NEED ANY MORE SMART-ALIKS like him in this world! He’s a poor example of how to act in society. The Idol judges were not as nasty to him as he was to them. He went on there to specifically show his butt to them and to the nation. He’s acting like a spoiled brat and America doesn’t need those examples shown everyday in our living rooms. Come on EXTRA, this guy’s had his day, now move on to someone worth watching and that has a better attitude about life. When you show him, I change the channel and hope other well-mannered citizens do the same.

Hey Ian.
Hello,I was watching extra last night and i saw that i could send a comment to you so i thought it was the perfect Opportunity to tell you that you are
f—king awesome!The way you told simon off was so true.People like him shouldn’t be judging.But anyways You could so be the next Mickey Avalon.
And if you putt out a cd I would be the first to buy it.Your so cool.
Keep it Up.
oh and good luck.
-allysin
Oh ps::i tryed to find you myspace but there is like 1354654320 people with your name, so can you add me?
www.myspace.com/51181050
thanks

yeah and kim..the other girl that commented let me just say that what he said about america being fat is true.
you bitches need to get up and jogg a couple laps.i mean seriously your probably what? 200 pounds?

hey heres a thought. for ya. what would you say to the paris hilton nicole richie fued? you should start your own branch of the simple life.

Ian, I think your comments about America being fat and you making that face were no better than Simon’s comments to you. You are NO better than he is and way to go stooping DOWN to his level.

IAN, LET ME JUST SAY U ROCK.SINCE THE 1ST APPPEARANCE U MADE I TOLD MY WIFE THIS GUY IS HILARIOUS. THERE IS NO SURPRISE THAT EXTRA IS GIVING U T.V TIME. IS THERE A CONTRACT U SAY FOR 15 YRS?,lol i really wish i was ur agent. i think american idol should let u fill in for SIMON should he be out, i think u are far more caritical than simon i think american will develop the love hate relationship they have with simon if u were to do an JUDGE APPEARANCE MAN I LOVE TO SEE THAT.

YOUR FAN JOHNNY
P.S. KEEP BEING WHO U ARE NASTY YET FUNNY