Comments (29)

On 11 Jan 2007, Louise wrote: I have watched American Idol since the first show aired…I wouldn’t miss it for any other show on T.V.

2432 agree

On 10 Jan 2007, tiana borris wrote: i’m looking forward to american idol,as usual,i like dancing with the stars too-but except for the first show,don’t get so involved in it.love amer.idol,the judges are a great team-it’s a winner!

0 agree

On 10 Jan 2007, tiana borris wrote: i’m looking forward to american idol,as usual,i like dancing with the stars too-but except for the first show,don’t get so involved in it.love amer.idol,the judges are a great team-it’s a winner!

0 agree

On 10 Jan 2007, tiana borris wrote: i’m looking forward to american idol,as usual,i like dancing with the stars too-but except for the first show,don’t get so involved in it.love amer.idol,the judges are a great team-it’s a winner!

0 agree

On 10 Jan 2007, Yvonne wrote: American Idol, it’s a no-brainer. I really think it’s a bad idea to air both at the same time for the simple reason; American Idol has been on longer and has a much stronger fan base.

0 agree

On 10 Jan 2007, Yolanda wrote: AMERICAN IDOL ALL THE WAY!! LOVE DANCING WITH THE STARS BUT AMERICAN IDOL IS THE WINNER AT OUR HOUSE!!

0 agree

On 10 Jan 2007, Ava wrote: I would watch American Idol. I think Simon is great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

0 agree

On 10 Jan 2007, Carolyn wrote: Definately American Idol is the one to watch. Dancing is a great show, just not in the same league. I love that they’re NOT on at the same time. I wouldn’t go there if I were “Dancing”!

0 agree

On 10 Jan 2007, Carolyn wrote: Definately American Idol is the one to watch. Dancing is a great show, just not in the same league. I love that they’re NOT on at the same time. I wouldn’t go there if I were “Dancing”!

0 agree

On 10 Jan 2007, Barnsinger wrote: Idol all the way!!! I love Dancing With the Stars, but it doesn’t hold a candle to Idol. Idol is an event; Dancing is just a TV show. Besides, only Idol has the incomparable SIMON COWELL!!!:) And it’s far more exciting to watch the process of finding a new singing star than to watch celebrities demonstrate their dance abilities.

0 agree

On 9 Jan 2007, Sherry wrote: Oh definitely Idol, it has everything that Dancing is missing, comedy (those attempting to “show their talent”), drama (the upset people not chosen), serious NON-talent, heck especially those that get on there thinking they know how to sing at the beginning, those are the best ones to watch. Dancing doesn’t have that at the start, and thats where AI catches and keeps hold of me. And it also has the things Dancing has, talent and loads of it. There would be no choice about it, American Idol all the way!!

0 agree

On 9 Jan 2007, Elaine wrote: I would most definitely watch Idol… no question.

0 agree

On 9 Jan 2007, Dan Duffy wrote: It really doesn’t matter what time Idol is on I won’t watch it. I mean,I might as well go down to the local bar for karaoke night. You’ve got talentless morons acting like, well, morons, and you’ve got nasty, ignorant people being judgmental. Their only redeeming quality is that they are usually drunk. What’s Simon’s excuse??? No, it’s Dancing for me, at least that takes SOME talent…

1 agree

On 9 Jan 2007, Roberta wrote: If Idol and Dancing are on at the same time I will watch Idol. Hope it doesn`t happen.

0 agree

On 9 Jan 2007, Karen wrote: I would choose Dancing with the Stars over Idol. Dancing With The Stars is my favorite show. I would record Idol and watch Dancing with the Stars. Then I could fast forward through all the crap on Idol that I am not interested in.

1 agree

On 9 Jan 2007, Lily wrote: If both shows were to air at the same time, I would choose my favorite -AMERICAN IDOL :-)

0 agree

On 9 Jan 2007, Muriel wrote: I’m not sure this is the right place, but I will watch both Dancing with the Stars and American Idol. VCR’s are wonderful inventions. Won’t miss either one of them.

0 agree

On 9 Jan 2007, Shelley wrote: I love both shows but American Idol wins my vote, I will tape Dancing with the stars to watch later. Lets hope they are not on at the same time, not a good idea.

0 agree

On 9 Jan 2007, Katy wrote: If American Idol and Dancing with the Stars are on at the same time, I will have a very difficult time making a decision. I love them both!!! I will be hoping it doesn’t happen. Hopefully I will be able to watch one and record the other if it does.

0 agree

On 9 Jan 2007, Elaine wrote: If the two shows were on at the same time, Dancing would be the big loser. I would definitely watch American Idol.

0 agree